Supreme Court divided on partisan gerrymandering

Credit: Reuters Studio
Published on March 27, 2019 - Duration: 01:52s

Supreme Court divided on partisan gerrymandering

The U.S. Supreme Court on Tuesday appeared divided along ideological lines again on whether the contentious practice of manipulating electoral district boundaries to entrench one party in power may violate the constitutional rights of voters, with Justice Brett Kavanaugh emerging as the potential deciding vote.

Colette Luke has more.

Supreme Court divided on partisan gerrymandering

In a case that could have sweeping influence over U.S. elections… the Supreme Court on Tuesday grappled with the contentious practice of gerrymandering… the reshaping of electoral districts to favor one political party over another… The court's nine justices heard arguments on the legality of North Carolina's Republican-drawn electoral map and a Democrat-drawn House district in Maryland.

Challengers asked the top court to set clear limits to gerrymandering for the first time..

But the justices appeared deeply divided on the issue along ideological lines… Conservative justices, such as Justice Samuel Alito were skeptical about empowering judges to block electoral maps drawn by state legislators… while liberal justices, such as Stephen Breyer, were open to letting the courts intervene..

The North Carolina case focuses on a 2016 map openly adopted to favor Republicans..

After a court found that an earlier map drawn by GOP legislators had unlawfully used race as a factor..

More than two dozen Democratic voters, the state's Democratic Party and two advocacy groups sued -- claiming partisan gerrymandering is unconstitutional.

During Tuesday's arguments, new justice Brett Kavanaugh took an active role… questioning whether the Supreme Court needed to intervene when there has been a "fair amount of activity" to remedy the situation in a given state, including the adoption of independent redistricting commissions… "Let's terminate gerrymandering!" Outside the court, former California Governor Arnold Schwarzenenger and Maryland Governor Larry Hogan led protests to end gerrymandering..

(SOUNDBITE) MARYLAND GOVERNOR LARRY HOGAN SAYING: "Both parties are guilty" The Supreme Court ruling is due by the end of June…

You are here

Recent related videos from verified sources

U.S. Court Orders Review Of Judge's Ruling To End Trump's Ban On Transgender Military Personnel 00:38
Credit: Wochit News - Published 2 days ago 

Top KS court OKs school funding but refuses to close lawsuit 03:04
Credit: 41 Action News - Published 2 days ago 

Spain's Supreme Court blocks Junqueras from joining EU parliament 02:29
Credit: Euronews English - Published 2 days ago 

US Court Rules Against Trump Administration In Abortions For unaccompanied Immigrant Minors 00:32
Credit: Wochit News - Published 2 days ago 

Idaho Supreme Court's misdemeanor ruling nets reaction from law enforcement, advocacy groups
Credit: KXLY - Published 3 days ago 

Idaho Supreme Court ruling on arrests 00:28
Credit: Idaho On Your Side - Published 4 days ago 

Supreme Court To Consider Bridgegate Appeal 00:25
Credit: CBS 2 New York - Published 4 days ago 

MN Supreme Court Justice Lillehaug To Resign In 2020 00:23
Credit: CBS 4 WCCO Minnesota - Published 5 days ago 

You might like