Supreme Court To Hear Oral Arguments in Gerrymandering Cases

Credit: Newsy Studio
Published on March 25, 2019 - Duration: 01:22s

Supreme Court To Hear Oral Arguments in Gerrymandering Cases

In the past, the justices agreed that partisan gerrymandering can be unconstitutional in some cases, but they haven’t been able to set a standard.


Supreme Court To Hear Oral Arguments in Gerrymandering Cases

The U.S. Supreme Court is taking another shot at an issue it's notoriously sidestepped: partisan gerrymandering.

The justices  will hear cases  from  North Carolina  and  Maryland  this week.  But it's a bit of a sticky situation for the high court.

In the past, the justices have agreed that partisan gerrymandering  can be unconstitutional  in some cases, but they haven’t been able to set a standard.  Last year, the Supreme Court heard two gerrymandering cases but avoided making a final decision in both, sending one back to a lower court.

And in 2015, the court voted 5-4 to give  redistricting permissions  in Arizona to an independent commission.  Chief Justice John Roberts wrote a dissenting opinion in that case, arguing the decision unconstitutionally took power from the legislature to draw congressional lines.  Roberts  expressed concern  with the upcoming gerrymandering cases, saying the court would have to act as a referee during oral arguments.  The North Carolina case hopes to answer three questions, including whether the congressional map was an "unconstitutional partisan gerrymander" skewed towards Republicans.

And in the Maryland case, the plaintiffs argue that the congressional district was "gerrymandered to retaliate against them for their political views," unfairly favoring Democrats.  Additional reporting from  Newsy affiliate CNN .

You are here

Recent related videos from verified sources

State Supreme Court Hears Oral Argument On Extending Deadline In UPMC-Highmark Dispute 03:18
Credit: KDKA CBS 2 Pittsburgh - Published on May 17, 2019 

U.S. top court to rule on citizenship question 02:09
Credit: Reuters Studio - Published on April 23, 2019 

You might like